A Trans Critique of Trans Rights

Share
A Trans Critique of Trans Rights

To be a trans person is to be a person with a gender identity distinct from the one assigned to you at birth. Gender identity refers to your own concept of yourself in gender terms such as masculinity, femininity, homosexuality, heterosexuality, bisexuality, woman, man, nonbinary, etc. While gender identity has seemingly existed as long as humans have been around, and thus there have always been people with gender identities that don’t match the dominant social norms (.e.g. non-binary gender identities in indigenous societies) the idea of making one’s gender identity primarily a matter of one’s individual expression and personal lifestyle is a modern one. Like everything else in modernity gender has wrenched itself from the clutches of cultural social control and made into a struggle for self-determination. Thus we get the modern queer, or LGBT social movement in which gender and sexual minorities challenge the dominant assumptions of cisheteronormativity that prevail in capitalist geoculture.  (Geoculture refers to the dominant norms of a world-system such as the modern capitalist world-economy.)

A cis person is a person who identifies with the gender identity they were assigned at birth. A heterosexual is someone who is sexually attracted to the opposite gender. Cisheteronormativity is the set of cultural norms that reinforces heterosexual and cisgender identity as the norm and marginalizes all other identities as deviant. Like movements against racial discrimination the queer movement has often adopted a ‘civil rights’ language in which the goal of the movement is reputed to be the achievement of legal protections for gender and sexual minorities which prevent discrimination against us. As such the increased visibility of trans people in the new millennium has led activists to talk about ‘trans rights’ especially against the onslaught against us by partisans and political forces of cisheteronormativity. However, I contend that the discourse about rights is not suited to our liberation.

To say that trans people have rights that need protecting by political power is to presuppose an antagonistic division of society into queer people and our allies and all others who wish to suppress our visibility and self-determination. It is this division which rationalizes the idea that x has rights against y. The same principle goes for any minority group claiming any kind of rights as well as individuals claiming rights against any sort of political, economic, or cultural power. Thus the idea of rights belongs to a liberal ideological dispensation, not in the sense that only liberals can make use of the concept, but in the sense that it derives from the liberal idea of a social contract.

Going back to Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau, the idea of a social contract is the idea that society is divided into competing interest groups that nonetheless have common interests, meaning that they ultimately must form an agreement which binds them all together according to a static conception of who is owed what and what is obligated to whom. The claim that trans people, or anyone else, has *rights* is thus to claim there is a fundamentally adversarial aspect of human social life that can only be overcome via a political power that subordinates all particular interests to a general interest which none the less expresses those particular interests. Thus every *right* comes with a corresponding *obligation*. When South Africans ended white minority rule under the system of Apartheid their newfound rights of social integration, political representation, and equality before the law came with a corresponding obligation to respect the property rights of the erstwhile white elite such that wealth and political power are still monopolized by the white minority even after the replacement of ethnocracy with liberal democracy.1 When black Americans ended a similar system of apartheid against them in the form of Jim Crow segregation they made a very similar trade off such that even though they could now occupy the same social spaces as whites and enjoy the same legal protections systematic underinvestment and overpolicing in their communities has subjected them to a system of capital accumulation that benefits white Americans and disadvantages black, Latino, and indigenous Americans in terms of employment, education, political power, incarceration, and police violence.

The achievement of rights for trans people in the United States, for instance, has already and will continue to come with similar trade offs. Wherever trans people and their allies have elected politicians friendly to their interests, or won legal campaigns, they have been politically obligated by American liberal democracy to respect the constitutionally guaranteed right of anti-trans movements and leaders to carry out their own successful campaigns against these very ‘rights’. The same has gone for all queer people and for women in this country since its founding and for every other minority in a liberal democratic state. Trans rights, whatever benefits they bring to trans people, mean the continued ensnaring of queer and trans people within the coercive designs of political power.

The alternative to rights discourse is the Anarchist concept of total liberation. Total liberation sets as the goal for all marginalized people and entities a world characterized by voluntary association and mutual benefit among all, rather than social conflict and coercive political power. Giving x rights against y on the assumption of conflict, rather than voluntary and mutually beneficial relations between x and y is dispensed with. Each agent is guaranteed self-determination by the constitution of society and no agent is given the material capacity to deny any other agent that self-determination. Rather than depending on formal legal entitlements and the coercive, hierarchical machinery which back them up, society is organized such that material control over one’s own life and circumstances is a feature of every individual’s existence. In such a society there would be no swinging pendulum between cisheteronormativity and the self-expression and inclusion of queer people. Only the full psychological and material expression of each human individual is the overriding geocultural norm. 
1. Dov Waxman explains this in his scholarly exposition of the 'Israel-Palestine Conflict', bringing up the example as a point of comparison for what could happen to Palestinians even if they are given equal rights in a bi-national state.
Sources
Democracy: A Very Short Introduction, Zack
Gender: What Everyone Needs to Know, Erickson-Schroth and Davis
Critical Race Theory: An Introduction, Delgado and Stefancic
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberalism/
The History of Philosophy, Grayling
Anarchism: Key Concepts, Honeywell
Modernism and Fascism, Griffin
World-Systems Analysis: An introduction

Read more

নৈরাজ্যবাদী শ্রমিক-সংঘের নীতিমালা

নৈরাজ্যবাদী শ্রমিক-সংঘের নীতিমালা

লেখাটি মূলত Anarcho-Syndicalist Principles শিরোনামে ইউটিউবে প্রকাশিত একটি আলাপের ভাবানুবাদ। অন্তত এক যুগ আগে, অ্যানার্কো-সিন্ডিক্যালিস্ট সংগঠনগুলোর সাংগঠনিক কাঠামো ও নীতিমালার মধ্যকার পারস্পরিক সম্পর্ক নিয়ে বক্তব্যটি প্রদান করেছেন বেঞ্জামিন স্মিথ, যিনি (IWA)-এর অস্ট্রেলীয় শাখা 'ASF'-এর সদস্য।

By Kazi Tanvir Hossain